--- title: "4 Examples of What Skills-Based Hiring Is Not | CoderPad" description: "There's a lot of talk about what skills-based hiring is… but little about what it is not. Here are four real-life examples of hiring practices that may look like skills-based hiring… but really aren’t." canonical: "https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/4-examples-of-what-skills-based-hiring-is-not/" last_modified: "2026-04-15 16:19:23" --- [Back to blog](https://coderpad.io/blog/) # 4 Examples of What Skills-Based Hiring Is Not January 18, 2024 5 Minute Read By Nathalie Figuière [Hiring Developers](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/) It’s January. I’m seeing TA professionals roll up their sleeves, ready to [get stuck into 2024](https://coderpad.io/events/tech-recruitment-trends-what-to-plan-for-in-2024/), armed with all sorts of good intentions. I’m seeing them commit to getting to grips with skills-based hiring: understanding what it means for them, how it may influence their hiring habits this year, how they can put it into practice… And while I’m convinced that it’s never been easier to “do” skills-based hiring, and that there are many resources and tools available, I feel like something might be missing. Indeed, I’ve read a lot about what skills-based hiring is… but heard little about what it is not. I’ve collected some real-life examples from conversations with recruiters and hiring managers in my network. Here are four down-to-earth examples of hiring practices that may look, sound or feel like skills-based hiring… but really aren’t. ## Experience does not necessarily equate to skills Picture this: You’re hiring a back-end engineer. You’ve identified a list of key skills required for this particular role. Proficiency in Java is at the top of your list. You post a job description where it is clearly stated that Java is a necessary skill to be successful in the role. You begin to receive applications. You select candidates with 5 or more years of Java experience and pass them through to the first stage of your process. What’s the catch? Objectively enumerating the necessary skills for a role (both technical skills and soft skills) is a must, the 101 of skills-based hiring, if you will. However, it’s not enough. If you don’t then go on to objectively evaluate those skills… *fervently shakes head*. While professional and personal experience are an integral part of what a candidate can bring to your role and company, experience does not necessarily equate to skills. A developer with 5+ years of experience with Java won’t necessarily have the level of mastery you’re looking for. Similarly, a candidate with less years of experience, may well surprise you. What to do instead: Instead of setting experience requirements, give everyone a chance to prove their skills. Assess their Java proficiency through an asynchronous coding test and a structured, collaborative programming interview. Ideally, send a reasonable and engaging technical test to anybody and everybody who’s interested in your opening. If that’s simply not feasible, try to hone in on the most objective and relevant screening criteria possible. That could be team-lead experience, startup vs. enterprise experience, b2b vs. b2c experience, knowledge of specific industries… That shouldn’t be age, gender, level of education, specific school, specific company, specific number of years of experience… ## The interview question pick ‘n’ mix Picture this: You’re working on creating a structured, standardized interview process. You compile a list of interview questions that are likely to provide you with a deeper understanding of a candidate’s skills. You provide your interview panel with this list ahead of time and encourage them to draw from it during their discussion. What’s the catch? Standardizing and scripting your interview questions is a step towards objective skills analysis. However, this initiative becomes counterproductive when questions are then chosen arbitrarily during the interview. If you’re not asking candidates the same questions, to assess the same skills, you’re creating room for bias and you’re making fair and objective comparison much more difficult. What to do instead: True skills-based hiring demands a more deliberate approach. Ensure that interview questions are standardized and directly aligned with specific skills, rather than a haphazard selection. Make sure that each person on the interview panel knows which questions they are responsible for asking. Bonus tip: you also want to determine, in advance, what bad, good and excellent candidate responses look like. ## This skill, or that skill, or maybe this skill Picture this: You’re hiring an applications developer. You’ve collaborated with the hiring manager to establish a list of necessary hard and soft skills for the role. You’ve worked on a plan to assess each of these skills. You agree that you won’t be able to assess all of the skills listed, in depth, during the hiring process. Depending on candidates’ resume and past experiences, you choose to assess what seems most relevant (gray areas, non-negotiables, areas of particular interest…). What’s the catch? Listing the necessary skills for the role? Yes. Testing different candidates on different skills? No. What to do instead: It’s unlikely that you’ll be able to evaluate every single skill that might come in useful for a role during your recruitment process. However, to be able to make fair, skills-based hiring decisions, you need to assess each applicant on the same set of skills. This will provide you with an objective basis for comparison. Prioritize in advance, select the “must-have skills” for the position and align on how you’ll evaluate them. ## Laying the groundwork… and ending up at the bar Picture this: The HR team puts time and effort into building an internal process, writing detailed job descriptions, standardizing candidate communications, etc. Candidates move through a short, engaging and structured process. Those that make it through to the technical interview meet the hiring manager. The hiring manager “talks shop”, and digs deep into varying technical subjects and interests, during a natural and enjoyable conversation. What’s the catch? I’m not saying that an interview can’t be enjoyable. I’m not saying that you don’t want to put candidates at ease. However, I am saying that a “beer test” type interview introduces tons of bias and will pull you away from a skills-based approach. You can lay all of the groundwork, your process loses its integrity as soon as hiring managers resort to subjective judgments based on personal feelings rather than a candidate’s demonstrated skills. What to do instead: Work on building a strong relationship with hiring managers. Support and coach them. If they understand what you’re trying to do and why, they’re more likely to welcome new habits. Structure, collaboration and assuming good intentions can go a long way. ## Subscribe for more CoderPad insights ## Trending Articles Previous slide Next slide [Hiring Developers ## 5 Ways to Strengthen Collaboration Between Talent Acquisition and Engineering Hiring Managers Alignment between talent acquisition and engineering managers is essential for hiring top developer talent. Read expert insights on how to improve collaboration. Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/strengthen-collaboration-talent-acquisition-engineering-hiring-managers/) [Hiring Developers ## Building a Diverse Tech Workforce: A 10-Step Guide to Reducing Hiring Bias Diversify your tech workforce: 10 steps to reduce hiring bias and attract top talent from diverse backgrounds Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/10-steps-to-reduce-hiring-bias-and-improve-diversity-in-tech/) [Hiring Developers ## ChatGPT & Technical Hiring: Q&A We hosted a webinar on ChatGPT & Technical Hiring. We didn't have time to answer all of your questions on the day. We do so here! Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/chatgpt-technical-hiring-post-webinar-qa/) [Hiring Developers ## How to Hire for AI Fluency Now That It’s a Critical Skill Based on the CoderPad webinar featuring Bayo Ojuri (CoderPad), Bonnie Dilber (Zapier), and Melany Austin (GoDaddy). “AI fluency” has quietly become a line item in nearly every technical job description. The problem: most teams added the requirement long before they had a reliable way to assess it. You can ask a candidate whether they use […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/how-to-hire-for-ai-fluency-now-that-its-a-critical-skill/) [Hiring Developers ## Hot Takes on Hiring: “AI Fluency” Is a Myth Our CEO, Amanda Richardson, and our Head of Product, Frank Hauben, can’t agree on anything else. We put Amanda and Frank on camera, handed them five spicy hot takes about AI in hiring, and told them not to sit on the fence. They sat on the fence anyway. Here’s what they actually fought about. Amanda […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/hot-takes-on-hiring-ai-fluency-is-a-myth/) [Hiring Developers ## 5 Unfiltered Takes on AI That Engineering Leaders Actually Believe We put a room full of senior engineering leaders together, took away the slides, added beer, and asked them to say the thing they’d never put in a LinkedIn post. No PR-approved talking points, no vendor gloss, just people who ship for a living telling the truth about what AI is doing inside their orgs […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/5-unfiltered-takes-on-ai-that-engineering-leaders-actually-believe/) [Hiring Developers ## Your Developer Interview Loop Is a Year Old. Is It Still Finding Your Best Candidates? A YC-backed founder called me last week with some good questions. His 20-person startup hadn’t hired an engineer in over a year. Now they’re opening reqs again, and instead of just dusting off the old loop, he wanted to understand how interviews had changed and if candidates were ready for AI interviews. His process — […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/your-developer-interview-loop-is-a-year-old-is-it-still-finding-your-best-candidates/) [Hiring Developers ## AI Fluency Is the New Technical Skill. Is Your Hiring Process Ready? Artificial intelligence has fundamentally changed software development. Developers are no longer working in isolation, writing every line of code from memory. AI has become part of the engineering workflow, helping developers brainstorm approaches, generate boilerplate code, and debug complex issues. The question isn’t whether engineers are using AI. It’s how effectively they’re using it. Hiring […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/ai-fluency-is-the-new-technical-skill-is-your-hiring-process-ready/) [Hiring Developers ## AI Didn’t Kill Entry Level Hiring. Bad Screening Did. For the last two years, the narrative has been loud, confident, and mostly wrong: AI is coming for entry level engineering jobs. The story goes something like this: If AI can write code, summarize docs, generate tests, and debug basic issues, why would companies still hire junior engineers? It sounds logical. It is also incomplete. […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/ai-didnt-kill-entry-level-hiring-bad-screening-did/) [Hiring Developers ## The Resume Is Dead. Most Teams Just Haven’t Admitted It Yet. Resumes made sense when applying for a job took real effort. That era is over. AI lets candidates apply to hundreds of roles in the time it once took to write a single cover letter. Employer-side AI systems process the flood. The result is a hiring funnel built almost entirely on artificial signals, where the […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/the-resume-is-dead-most-teams-just-havent-admitted-it-yet/) [Hiring Developers ## Is Your Technical Hiring Process Screening Out Great Engineers? The short answer: Many technical hiring processes are doing the latter. High-friction interview loops, live coding under observation, and AI-restrictive assessments are measuring interview performance, not job performance. The fix isn’t rebuilding from scratch — it’s auditing whether your process measures engineering capability or something else entirely. If you attended our recent webinar with CoderPad […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/is-your-technical-hiring-process-screening-out-great-engineers/) [Hiring Developers ## Junior Developers Are Your Strategic Advantage—If You Can Actually Evaluate Them Campus recruiting season arrives the same way every year: hundreds of applications, a narrow window, and a process that was never designed for this much volume or this much pressure. Meanwhile, the definition of “technical skill” is actively shifting—AI-polished resumes have made traditional screening nearly meaningless, and the skills that predict junior developer success look […] Read the post](https://coderpad.io/blog/hiring-developers/junior-developers-are-your-strategic-advantage-if-you-can-actually-evaluate-them/) ## Hire with confidence. See why engineering teams trust CoderPad to evaluate developers with realistic, AI-ready hiring workflows. [Request a demo](https://coderpad.io/sales/)